| Year | Name | Director |
| 1992 1 | Arsenic & Old Lace | Lori Nussle |
| 1992 2 | Odd Couple | Martha Mack & Peg Crawford |
| 1992 3 | Born Yesterday | David Erickson |
| 1993 X | Handy Dandy | Don McGrew |
| 1993 1 | Rumours | Lori Nussle |
| 1993 2 | Steel Magnolias | Randy Mitchell |
| 1993 3 | Inherit the Wind | Jan Mitchell |
| 1994 1 | Music Man | STEVE Miller & DAVID Groebe |
| 1994 2 | Harvey | David Erickson |
| 1994 3 | The Foreigner | Lori Nussle |
| 1995 1 | It Runs in the Family | Peg Crawford |
| 1995 2 | Prelude to a Kiss | Lori Nussle |
| 1995 3 | Scrooge | Joyce Harley |
| 1996 1 | Lend Me a Tenor | Lori Nussle |
| 1996 2 | The Good Doctor | Frann Carnivelle |
| 1996 3 | DRACULA | Paul Carvey |
| 1997 1 | Divorce , Anyone? | Steve Bell |
| 1997 2 | NUNSENSE | Len Wcislo |
| 1997 3 | Mad Woman of Chaillot (the) | Jean Moran |
| 1998 1 | Man who Came to Dinner (The ) | Peg Crawford |
| 1998 2 | Sunshine Boys (The ) | Lori Nussle |
| 1998 3 | SCROOGE | Steve Bell |
| 1999 1 | Sylvia | Lori Nussle |
| 1999 2 | Nunsense II | Len Wcislo |
| 1999 3 | Not Now Darling | Jan Mitchell |
| 2000 1 | MURDER BY MISADVENTURE | David Groebe |
| 2000 2 | PICASSO AT THE LAPIN AGILE | Lori Nussle |
| 2000 3 | LIGHT UP THE SKY | Peg Crawford |
| 2001 1 | Witness for the Prosecution | Steve Bell |
| 2001 2 | Snow Jobs | George Machay |
| 2001 3 | Lucky Stiff | Lori Nussle |
| 2002 1 | Barefoot in the Park | Steve Bell |
| 2002 2 | Over the River & Thru the Woods | Shirley Hulse |
| 2002 3 | Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum (A ) | Lori Nussle |
| 2002 xx | Groucho | Len Wcislo |
| 2003 1 | Social Security | Peg Crawford |
| 2003 2 | Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 | George Machay |
| 2003 3 | Gazebo (the ) | Jan Mitchell |
| 2004 1 | Out of Order | Peg Crawford |
| 2004 2 | One Act Buffet | Steve Bell |
| 2004 3 | My Favorite Year | Lori Nussle |
| 2005 1 | Broadway Bound | Peg Crawford |
| 2005 2 | All in the Timing | Wally Roche |
| 2005 3 | The Apple Tree | George Machay |
| 2006 1 | Perfect Wedding (The ) | Lori Nussle |
| 2006 2 | Dining Room (The) | DAVID GROEBE |
| 2006 3 | Senior Follies | George Machay |
| 2007 1 | I Love You, You’re Perfect…. | Lori Nussle |
| 2007 2 | Curious Savage | Carol Kearney |
| 2007 3 | Uninvited (The ) | Steve Bell |
| 2008 1 | Heidi Chronicles (The) | Lori Nussle |
| 2008 2 | I Hate Hamlet | Len Wcislo |
| 2008 3 | Funny Money | Jan Mitchell |
| 2009 1 | Philadelphia Story (The) | David Groebe |
| 2009 2 | Don’t Drink The Water | Julie Zebleckis |
| 2009 3 | Lion in Winter ( The ) | Christine Haines |
| 2010 1 | Leading Ladies | Lori Nussle |
| 2010 2 | Enchanted April | Peg Crawford |
| 2010 3 | She Loves Me | George Machay |
| 2011 1 | SEX PLEASE, Were Sixty | Len Wcislo |
| 2011 2 | LAURA | David Groebe |
| 2011 3 | ONE FLEW OVER THE CUKOO’S NEST | Steve Bell |
| 2012 1 | Deadman’s Cell Phone | Lori Nussle |
| 2012 2 | Cocktails with Mimi | Julie Zebleckis |
| 2012 3 | Rehearsal for Death | Mike Gandy |
| 2013 1 | Crossing Delancey | Ken Evans |
| 2013 2 | One O’Clock from the House | David Grobe |
| 2013 3 | Once Upon A Mattress | Steve Bell |
| 2014 1 | Becky’s New Car | Len Wcislo |
| 2014 2 | My Three Angels | Peg Crawford |
| 2014 3 | These Shining Lives | Kevin Haines |
| 2015 1 | God of Carnage | Lori Nussle |
| 2015 2 | The Mousetrap | Ken Evans |
| 2015 3 | Good People | Meghan Sterling |
| 2016 1 | Farragut North | Julie Zebleckis |
| 2016 2 | Arsenic and Old Lace | Julie Zebleckis |
| 2016 3 | Lend Me a Tenor | Lori Nussle |
| 2017 1 | The Game’s Afoot | Jimmy Mazeika |
| 2017 2 | Vanya, Sasha, Mosha and Spike | Bryan Riess |
| 2017 3 | The Producers | Gina Dunn |
| 2018 1 | Funny Thing Called Love | Lori Nussle |
| 2018 2 | And Then There Were None | Ken Evans |
| 2018 3 | The Drowsy Chaperone | Gina Dunn |
| 2019 1 | Rancho Mirage | Len Wcislo |
| 2019 2 | Dixie Swim Club | Lisa Glatz |
| 2019 3 | Laughter on the 23rd Floor | Bryan Riess |
| 2020 1,2 | COVID |
| 2020 3 | COVID |
| 2021 1,2,3 | COVID |
| 2021 3 | On Golden Pond | Len Wcislo |
| 2022 1 | The 39 Steps | Kim Dignin |
| 2022 2 | ART | Joanna Leafblad |
| 2022 3 | Something Rotten | Gina Lutvi |
| 2023 1 | All the Day | Sarah Callis |
| 2023 2 | Leaving Iowa | Julie Zebleckis |
| 2023 3 | TBA – Audience Choice | TBA |